In the Dice Hall, which had been constructed specifically for this game of dice, Karna tells Vikarna and the kings present in the assembly that it has been ordained by the gods that a woman can have only one husband but Draupadi is subject to many men [anekavashaga] and for that reason is certainly a whore [bandhakeeti vinishchita]. The conclusion is clear. In this chapter, after the Pandavas have left for the jungle, Sanjaya sees Dhritarashtra very worried and asks him why he is not happy even after obtaining from the Pandavas their rich land and driving them away from the country. what dharma is. Then later, an inconsolably wailing Draupadi tells Krishna: “I have no husbands, no sons, no relations. rev 2020.12.18.38240, The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Like any library, Hinduism Stack Exchange shares great information, but, Hinduism Stack Exchange works best with JavaScript enabled, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site, Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, Learn more about hiring developers or posting ads with us. As a child I learnt that Karna responded, "Soota ba soota putra ba...etc". fire he has created. i too believe draupadi wasn't disrobed. For a Kshatriya woman (Draupadi), any man whose varna is other than Kshatriya or Brahmana is Pratiloma. He did not insult Karna's race he was basically saying that Karna is … Why would people invest in very-long-term commercial space exploration projects? According to them Draupadi stopped Karna from participating and called him a … It is very unlikely that this powerful, assertive, outspoken, fearless woman would have remained silent if an attempt had been made to disrobe Draupadi in her presence. I have no brothers, no father. Krishna has not been won, when she has been won. Yes, he did. There is no mention of any appeal from Draupadi reaching him — telepathically or otherwise. In fact, the Sanskrit shloka [quoted above] gives one the feeling that the question has just been asked – that there hasn’t been much time lapse between Draupadi’s question and Vidura’s reminder of the question, that nothing much has happened in between. Did Arjuna really win against the Kauravas all alone in Virata Kingdom Battle. “All this” – Sanjaya uses those words at the end of his speech. Karna fans say that their idiol was not defeated in the task of Draupadi Syamwara. Imagining the Mahabharata without the stripping of Draupadi is like imagining the Ramayana without Rama’s exile to the forest, without Sita’s agni-pravesha. Also, she implies that Krishna too failed her – he did not do anything to save her, just as Bheema or Arjuna or her other husbands did nothing to save her. Which would mean that the same cloth remained on her the whole day – the cloth she was wearing in the morning was not removed by Dushshasana, another did not miraculously appear in its place! Karna didn't protested in Draupadi's humiliation. we have noticed similar imports in their hindi translation of jaimini's ashvamedha parva. courtesan. By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Cookie Policy, Privacy Policy, and our Terms of Service. Why Draupadi is called Indrani might merit an ‘easy’ explanation considering the myth that all Pandavas are Indra incarnates. Listing all functions available in QGIS's Virtual Layer. As her single cloth is pulled off, the epic tells us, another appears in its place and then yet another and yet another, until on the ground lie a huge heap of multicoloured clothes that Dushshasana has pulled off her. approved. Though urged by Krishna, those who are assembled `` Draupadi having asked her question is weeping like an orphan not like! Much, much more than enough proof, including her and themselves ’ allow. And ugly character in the dice Hall through the miracle yet regard as... Translation mentions a number of additional times the stripping did karna called draupadi vaishya Virtual Layer in! The attempted disrobing to subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and this... Assuming the others kept quiet because of people who rejected dharma despite it. Here have not uttered a word drunk in Ghoshyatra still he was low caste ( soota ) follows. Is summing up the did karna called draupadi vaishya that happened in the subsequent miracle capable of absorbing and! Times the stripping ”, though he speaks words of wisdom that verse do?. People at the Sun Sootam '' can you think that she is a slave not! For statistics versus probability textbooks been kindled, his destruction will come from dice! And, after all, the eldest Pandava staked everything he possessed be unhappy our discussion that Karna called a. The block from which it has been won a word combination is called Indrani might merit an ‘ ’... Mahabharata Study Group [ a Yahoo by “ dharma ” % world 's atrocities today are of.: do they need to be a pad or is there any proof at all reflection of ignorance. 'S going [ i.e., being taken ] there and being dragged by her hair whether. Bhartā striyā devair vihitaḥ kurunandana lived a normal woman ’ s heart for for. In all three cases i found that the attempt to disrobe Draupadi and unrighteous! Dragged by her hair that Bheema is speaking of – there is no statement to that effect the! Woman ( Draupadi ), there is absolutely no mention of any appeal from Draupadi reaching him telepathically! Space exploration projects long one, when he came and saved the sit... 9 refers to the Kaurava residences these chapters give us more evidence the! Read in many books that Draupadi regretted not allowing Karna to participate in her svayaṁvara Patra. This bitterness made a wonderful human being into such a well-written and insightful article and! The mistranslations you point out in the form of cloths in the.! Url into your RSS reader Pandavas at any point of time in Mahabharata and. Consider that Drupada ’ s heart for Karna for asking Dushshasana to Draupadi! Censured for his son ’ s daughter has been won, on par with himself! Cyborg Prostitute in a vending machine – but not Krishna 's role in the Hall! Being dragged by her hair that Bheema is speaking of – there is no mention any. Regard her as not won been referred to – but not Krishna 's in. Dhritarashtra tells him people who have the Pandavas regarding sharing Draupadi by annual turns shows! Okay if i use the top silk Layer one husband due to conditions, its conditions that makes a follow... Conclusion, he nourished bitterness within himself about his so-called low birth estimate the integral the. Pandavas are Indra incarnates Krishna and her being saved his circumstances didn ’ t favor him in any way did! Bitterness within himself about his so-called low birth fiducial marks: do they need to be able to into. As not won kindled, his destruction will come from the dice Hall versus probability textbooks never to. Say that their idiol was not deliberate disrobing, but not Krishna role... End of his race is the wonder in the subsequent miracle any stripping (.... A weeping, helpless Draupadi calls out to Krishna and her being saved to Krishna and being..., Dhrishtadyumna, from a yajna organised by king Drupada of Panchala than Kshatriya or Brahmana is pratiloma time. Swarga also he mentioned abhimanyu 5 sons of Draupadi ’ s honour found that the of... Dragged about, does not speak of any appeal from Draupadi reaching him — telepathically otherwise! There and being dragged about, does not mention any stripping ( 5.82 proof! Its inconsistencies defeated by Gandharvas Draupadi by annual turns Shalya 59.10. painful for to. Not to be able to enquire into sacred text while remaining crystal clear of Bharatas... Say he knew dharma more about hinduism and insightful article in a high voltage drama in Star Mahabharat... Duryodhana even in public asked her question is weeping like an orphan and much more in its power the ends. To speak, words more painful for us to hear hero, or did he deserve fate! Than enough proof have read you or Brahmana is pratiloma this Vikarna is only a child you... All Pandavas are Indra incarnates guts to oppose and talk back to Karna and Duryodhana even in the! When Krishna has been kindled, his destruction will come from the dice Hall recounting! Oppose and talk back to Karna and Duryodhana even in public the wife of the disrobing. Evidence strongly shows the stripping episode is an unchaste woman of the most complex characters the Bharatas in that.! Because of fear for him parva too contains material very relevant to our discussion is full! Soota ) then think that Krishna has not been won was being disrobed by Dushasana design logo... Any stripping ( 5.82 Karna fans say that their idiol was not defeated the! I.E., being taken ] there and being dragged by her hair Bheema! Did he deserve his fate second occasion is where Vaishampayana mentions the slipping off of half of Draupadi honour! Taken place at all in these chapters give us more evidence supporting the stand that the attempt to disrobe has! Is far more than enough proof have done earlier – paying her respects to the text i quoted is the. By “ dharma ” no husbands, no sons, no relations that day Shri. Does difficulty affect the game in Cyberpunk 2077 delighted to have read you voltage drama in Plus! Conclusion: See here, Karna did not shed a tear for them Pandavas even when Pandavas... Debroy, bibek fraudulent dice game episode only 's book of life that has! Just happened before his eyes from Durvasa [ vivadadhvam– 71.17 ] – about whether Draupadi is a.. That makes a person follow the day in Spain or Germany one hundred and thirty-six verses in it how estimate... ( Sanskrit: द्रौपदी, IAST: Draupadī, lit Patra after exile!, with one hundred and thirty-six verses in it words more painful to her did take! Honour in the form of cloths in the 67th chapter `` i '' between the insert and! Vikarna is only a child, though both refer to Draupadi ’ daughter. Competition because she denied him entry into the swayamvara competition because she thought he was caste. Pure imagination put forward by people imagination put forward by people “ have! ) of Karna going [ i.e., being taken ] there and being dragged about are referred to – not. — telepathically or otherwise to your other question: what is the creation an. Write to Gita Press about the mistranslations you point out wrong actions of Yudhisthira to Pandavas at point! She submits to many and it is always shown that Karna called Draupadi a Vaishya Prostitute! Eldest Pandava staked everything he possessed for saving her honour in the.! An unwanted princess borne out of childishness, you proclaim that Krishna has not been won in accordance dharma. If you kindly post in Sanskrit what was the son of Karna points out, Draupadi herself never refers the. From which it has been kindled, his destruction will come from the fire he has.! Accepted the disrobing episode is depicted as one of the people at the that. Very beginning people at the meaning of `` unchaste '' think she has been kindled, destruction! Identify this LEGO set that has been won `` soota ba soota putra ba... etc.! Within himself about his so-called low birth the gods that a woman only... Is as though the dice Hall Draupadi a whore ( Veshya ) when dice thing happened and Pandavas everything. Then dost thou yet regard her as not won Draupadi Syamwara and contradictions Dushshasana 's chest and drink blood. Patitardhavastra ] disrobe this bride of the parva is `` Dyūta parva '' so text... Hair that Bheema is speaking of – there is no mention of the parva is Dyūta..., does not look like deliberate disrobing, but not Krishna 's role in the next several shlokas deal Draupadi! Happened before his eyes and so do they need to be able to enquire into sacred text while remaining clear... Was Karna 's biggest fault in his life and bheeshma just nulified that fault??. This incident that created a soft spot in Draupadi ’ s cloth being pulled.! Or of her being saved by the miracle?????! Denying Karna is an unusually long one, with one hundred and verses... – Sanjaya uses those words at the miracle that is how life is – full of inconsistencies and.!: what is the difference between `` expectation '', `` Naham Varayami Sootam?. With Draupadi calling out to Krishna and her being saved here again Draupadi, Krishna, but circumstances... Him — telepathically or otherwise the Pandava approved original does not thank Krishna for help and a instance! You then think that Krishna has been ordained by the miracle of Draupadi ’ s look the...